Weld neck vs slip-on flange
Both are ASME B16.5 flanges that bolt up the same way. The difference is how they join the pipe, and that changes their strength, inspection and cost.
Weld neck
A weld neck flange has a long tapered hub that ends in a bevel. It is butt welded to the pipe, and its bore matches the pipe bore. The taper spreads stress smoothly from the flange ring into the pipe, and the butt weld can be fully radiographed.
Slip-on
A slip-on flange slides over the pipe and is held by two fillet welds, one at the hub outside and one inside at the face. It is cheaper to buy, and easier to line up because the pipe can be cut a little long and slid into place.
Side by side
| Weld neck | Slip-on | |
|---|---|---|
| Joint to pipe | One full-penetration butt weld | Two fillet welds |
| Strength and fatigue | Best: tapered hub, no sharp change | Lower; fatigue life is commonly quoted at about a third of a weld neck |
| Inspection | Butt weld can be radiographed | Fillet welds: surface methods only |
| Flange cost | Higher | Lower |
| Fit-up | Pipe must be cut to length | Easier, some length adjustment |
| Typical use | High pressure or temperature, cyclic or hazardous service, all classes | Low pressure utilities (water, air), mostly Class 150 and 300 |
Which to choose
Use weld necks for process lines, hot or cyclic service, and anything toxic or flammable. Slip-ons save money on low-pressure utility lines where the piping class allows them. B31.3 warns against slip-on flanges where many large temperature cycles are expected, and many project specifications restrict them further.
For cut lengths, remember the two flanges sit differently: the pipe ends at the weld neck bevel, but goes into the slip-on almost up to the face.
Common questions
Is a slip-on flange weaker than a weld neck?
Yes. Its calculated strength under internal pressure is lower, and its fatigue life is much shorter, which is why it is kept to mild, low-pressure service.
Do slip-on flanges need two welds?
Yes, a fillet weld at the back of the hub and another inside at the face. The inside weld must not stick out past the face.
Can I use a slip-on flange on a hot line?
Avoid it where the line heats and cools many times. B31.3 warns against it, and most project specifications only allow slip-ons in mild utility service.
More guides
General engineering guidance for learning and early design. Your project specifications and the governing code edition always take precedence.